Best Mary Kay Mascara Reviews and Buying Guide

Ensuring the quality of a product on which you have your eyes for a long time can be tricky. For every product in the market, there are several models and competitors available. And relying only on reviews is not always the best way of picking the best Mary Kay Mascara, and I will tell you why!

The reviews we usually check on the internet before getting our hands on a product typically have the same chatter. These reviews are usually dotted with similar patterns to highlight the pros and cons to help you make a decision. However, a good review consists of more than just the features, pros, and cons.

After deep research and scanning through the market well, we have prepared this guide for you. Here, we will share the details of the best products and how to choose them properly. So, stay with us till the end of the guide.

Follow This Table To Quickly Select The Best Product

As an Amazon Associate, we earn from qualifying purchases. For more details, read here.

Place Image Product Information Score
1 Mary Kay Ultimate Mascara/Black Mary Kay Ultimate Mascara Black by Mary
9.1
2 Mary Kay Lash Love Mascara in BLACK Mary Kay Lash Love Mascara in BLACK by Mary
9.8
3 Mary Kay Ultimate Mascara 0.28 Net WT / 8 g - Black/Brown Mary Kay Ultimate Mascara Net WT g by Mary
9.8
4 Mary Kay Lash Intensity Mascara .32 oz. - Black Mary Kay Lash Intensity Mascara oz - by Mary
9.3
5 Mary Kay® Ultimate Mascara™: Black, 0.28 oz Mary Kay Ultimate Mascara Black oz by Mary
8.9
6 Mary Kay I ♥ Black Waterproof Lash Love Mascara Mary Kay I Black Waterproof Lash Love by Mary
9
7 Mary Kay? Lash Love Mascara in BLACK Mary Kay Lash Love Mascara in BLACK by Mary
9.4
8 Mary Kay Lash Love Fanorama Mascara 0.28 Net WT / 8 g - Black - Limited Edition Mary Kay Lash Love Fanorama Mascara Net by Mary
9.3
9 Mary Kay Waterproof Mascara in Black .33 oz Mary Kay Waterproof Mascara in Black oz by Mary
9.2
10 Mary Kay Lash Love Lengthening Mascara in Black Mary Kay Lash Love Lengthening Mascara in by Mary
9.5

Top 12 Best Mary Kay Mascara Reviews for 2023

SaleBestseller No. 1

Mary Kay Ultimate Mascara/Black

Popularity Score 9.4
Quality Score 9
Sentiment Score 9.8

Highlighted Features

  • Mary Kay Ultimate Mascara/Black

Additional Info :

Brand Mary
Color Unknown
Item Dimensions
Height 7
Width 21
Length 32
Weight 76.28
Bestseller No. 2

Mary Kay Lash Love Mascara in BLACK

Popularity Score 9.6
Quality Score 9.1
Sentiment Score 9.7

Highlighted Features

  • Mary Kay Lash Love Mascara
  • I Love Black
  • Travel Size tube

Additional Info :

Brand Mary
Color Unknown
Item Dimensions
Height 11
Width 35
Length 44
Weight 74.24
Bestseller No. 3

Mary Kay Ultimate Mascara 0.28 Net WT / 8 g - Black/Brown

Popularity Score 9.8
Quality Score 9
Sentiment Score 9.4

Highlighted Features

  • Flake -, clump- and smudge-resistant.
  • Ophthalmologist-tested; suitable for contact lens wearers.
  • Clinically tested for skin irritancy and allergy; suitable for sensitive eyes
  • Fragrance-free.
  • This extremely volumizing, superthickening, all-in-one formula creates the look of big, bold, separated lashes that last all day.

Additional Info :

Brand Mary
Color Black
Item Dimensions
Height 13
Width 23
Length 29
Weight 24.07
SaleBestseller No. 4

Mary Kay Lash Intensity Mascara .32 oz. - Black

Popularity Score 9.7
Quality Score 9
Sentiment Score 9.2

Highlighted Features

Additional Info :

Brand Mary
Color Multicolor
Item Dimensions
Height 17
Width 30
Length 24
Weight 41.01
SaleBestseller No. 5

Mary Kay® Ultimate Mascara™: Black, 0.28 oz

Popularity Score 9.1
Quality Score 9.4
Sentiment Score 9

Highlighted Features

  • Eyes

Additional Info :

Brand Mary
Color Off-white
Item Dimensions
Height 20
Width 31
Length 44
Weight 30.53
Bestseller No. 6

Mary Kay I ♥ Black Waterproof Lash Love Mascara

Popularity Score 9.6
Quality Score 9.7
Sentiment Score 8.9

Highlighted Features

  • Love your lashes with the mascara that defines, defends and delivers four times the volume while looking naturally flawless, soft and healthy. The flexible, sculpted brush separates and coats lashes.
  • Flake-, Smudge- and clump-resistant.
  • Mary Kay Panthenol-Pro Complex helps condition lashes and helps defend against breakage.
  • Ophthalmologist-tested and suitable for contact lens wearers.
  • Water-resistant formula. Fragrance-free.

Additional Info :

Brand Mary
Color White
Item Dimensions
Height 15
Width 35
Length 26
Weight 21.4
SaleBestseller No. 7

Mary Kay? Lash Love Mascara in BLACK

Popularity Score 9.2
Quality Score 9.3
Sentiment Score 9.3

Highlighted Features

Additional Info :

Brand Mary
Color Grey
Item Dimensions
Height 19
Width 43
Length 29
Weight 21.99
SaleBestseller No. 8

Mary Kay Lash Love Fanorama Mascara 0.28 Net WT / 8 g - Black - Limited Edition

Popularity Score 9.2
Quality Score 9.3
Sentiment Score 9

Highlighted Features

  • Catch everyone’s eye with a pair of ultrafluttery and fully fanned-out lashes. Use the three unique application zones – coat, comb and fan out – on the all-new brush to lift, separate and perfectly place each lash. Its zigzag design covers your lashes in the iconic Lash Love formula, while staggered rows of the soft, silicone bristles push as much pigment-rich mascara into lashes as possible. All-around, panoramic lash impact is now yours.
  • Dermatologist-tested.
  • Ophthalmologist-tested.
  • Tested for skin irritancy and allergy.
  • Suitable for sensitive eyes and contact lens wearers.

Additional Info :

Brand Mary
Color Black
Item Dimensions
Height 16
Width 31
Length 38
Weight 63.69
SaleBestseller No. 9

Mary Kay Waterproof Mascara in Black .33 oz

Popularity Score 9.7
Quality Score 8.9
Sentiment Score 9.7

Highlighted Features

Additional Info :

Brand Mary
Color Grey
Item Dimensions
Height 20
Width 44
Length 21
Weight 51.1
Bestseller No. 10

Mary Kay Lash Love Lengthening Mascara in Black

Popularity Score 9.7
Quality Score 9
Sentiment Score 9.8

Highlighted Features

Additional Info :

Brand Mary
Color Off-white
Item Dimensions
Height 19
Width 23
Length 45
Weight 34.01
Bestseller No. 11

Honest Beauty 2-in-1 Extreme Length Clean Mascara + Lash Primer | Lengthening + Volumizing | EWG Verified, Vegan + Cruelty Free | Black, .27 fl oz

Popularity Score 9.7
Quality Score 9.5
Sentiment Score 9.4

Highlighted Features

  • New look, same great formula; packaging may vary
  • Award-winning, bestselling double-sided mascara plus lash primer for ultimate length and volume
  • Ophthalmologist Tested
  • Cruelty free
  • EWG Certified

Additional Info :

Brand Honest
Color Unknown
Item Dimensions
Height 10
Width 32
Length 22
Weight 61.01
Bestseller No. 12

Mary Kay Lash Intensity Mascara 0.32 oz. - Black

Popularity Score 9.1
Quality Score 9.5
Sentiment Score 9.5

Highlighted Features

  • Magnify. Maximize. Multiply the look of your lashes. That’s intense!
  • Expand and extend with our only mascara dedicated to multidirectional performance.
  • With 200% more volume, it’s like adding the thickness of two lashes onto every one; plus, get 84% longer-looking lashes!*
  • Special Double-Impact brush designed to plump while combing through to lengthen the look of lashes.
  • Mineral-rich, high-impact pigment envelops each lash in a perfect shade of black.

Additional Info :

Brand Mary
Color Multicolor
Item Dimensions
Height 7
Width 37
Length 28
Weight 34.69

Why 1st Product is Best Compare to Others

1st product has many incredible facts over other products. That’s why we’ve ranked it on top of this list.

The excellent quality of a good product is that it will fulfill all the needs a user have and solve the real problem. These quality is exists on this product. Be understandable by users, perform users task as easily and efficiently as possible.

Bottom line, this product is finesse for use, features that meet consumer needs and give customer satisfaction and conformance to standards.

Thing to Consider Before Buying Best Mary Kay Mascara

When it comes to choosing a product from a wide range of options, several factors go into consideration. And this consideration includes factors such as price, quality, warranty, and many more. So, without further ado, let us dive deep into these factors.

Quality

The most important factor that needs to be considered when purchasing Mary Kay Mascaras is quality. Checking the quality of the product will help you to determine whether it is worth the money or not. And to ensure quality, make sure to check the certifications of the product. These certifications will give you a clear idea about the manufacturing practices used to maintain top-notch quality.

Features

A product comes with several features, and this is typically the deciding factor when it comes to choosing an item. Features in a product are an essential factor to consider as they refer to how the item benefits us. While a few items come with a wide range of features, not all of them are useful to us.

Check out the features of the [Mary Kay Mascara 02] and make sure that they meet the requirements you are looking for. Ensure these features and pick a product that matches your needs in the best possible manner.

Material

The next factor that requires proper attention is the material of the item. Each material has its quality and specialty. So considering it will give you a proper idea about the product. One product is available in a lot of material options as it varies from manufacturer to manufacturer. Comb through the available material options to pick one that matches your search. The best bet would be on the one that’s more durable and aesthetically pleasing.

Warranty

The warranty of an item is a clear sign that the manufacturers are confident about the product. However, not all manufacturers will provide you with a warranty, and this does not affect the quality of the product. But considering the warranty policy of an item can benefit you in several ways.

Check out if there is a warranty available and the terms and conditions associated with it. Make sure to go for the one with the warranty if the other factors match your search as well. This warranty will help you to get a return or replacement in case it fails to provide proper service. In a few cases, you will also be eligible for a full or partial refund.

Cost

While the cost is not the most important factor, it is still a key part of the demographic. However, completely basing the decision on the price is not a good idea. If you take a look at the market, you will notice that one product is available at a wide range of prices.

Finding a product that suits the budget while matching the requirements can be difficult, but not impossible. Research the Mary Kay Mascara options properly and make sure that the item fits the important factors and the budget.

Reviews and Feedback

Reviews and customer feedback on a product are typically where we focus the most. These reviews usually come from the personal experience of the customers, and they usually talk about the positive sides of the product. However, the feedback from the customers also reveals the negative aspects of the item.

The positivity of these reviews often influences the decision of the buyers. But the cons of this product rarely affect the decision. However, the negative aspects of the product prepare you for what to expect from the item.

FAQ

Properly researching Mary Kay Mascaras will help you to pick the right product from the market. Related questions often help us to solve a conflict that research and reviews cannot help with. So, know the answers to some of the frequently asked questions.

Is Purchase Mary Kay Mascara From Online Marketplace Worth It?

The online marketplace has both advantages and disadvantages. While you get a wider area to research and look for the product, scams or frauds are difficult to identify. However, if you properly research the item, then ordering Mary Kay Mascaras online is safe and worth it.

Can I Go For A Product Without A Warranty?

The warranty of a product works as an extra layer of security. It prevents the trouble of replacing the product and makes sure that you do not have to pay extra. However, many manufacturers do not include a warranty with their items.

If a warranty is available, then going for it is the best option. But if the product matches your requirements for features and quality, then a warranty is not the deciding factor.

CONCLUSION

In the current market, finding the perfect product often turns out to be a struggle. With so many replicas and copies available, getting your hands on an authentic product requires deep research. Not to mention the misleading reviews and advertisements that often influence our decisions.

So, make sure to rely on the buying guide and your research when choosing the best Mary Kay Mascara. Pay attention to the ratings and check out the detailed reviews to understand the ups and downs of the product. Be a smart customer and know your requirements well before diving into the market.

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *